The Study of Racialism Forum Index
The Study of Racialism
Discussion of U.S. Racialism
Please read The Rules before posting.
 
 FAQFAQ   SearchSearch     RegisterRegister 
   Log inLog in 
'

Why a "white" person would identify "black"?
Goto page 1, 2, 3, 4, 5  Next
 
Post new topic   This topic is locked: you cannot edit posts or make replies.    The Study of Racialism Forum Index -> Improving U.S. Society
Author Message
Patience
Mentor
Mentor


Joined: 13 Mar 2007
{Posts: 261 }
Location: Canada

PostPosted: Thu 26 Jul 2007 12:12    Post subject: Why a "white" person would identify "black"? Reply with quote

This is a question that comes up in this forum many times and I think part of the reason can be found in this article.

http://www.detnews.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20070719/METRO/707190419/1003
Back to top
Powell
Guru
Guru


Joined: 27 Nov 2004
{Posts: 2462 }

PostPosted: Thu 26 Jul 2007 19:53    Post subject: Re: Why a "white" person would identify "black"? Reply with quote

Patience wrote:
This is a question that comes up in this forum many times and I think part of the reason can be found in this article.

http://www.detnews.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20070719/METRO/707190419/1003


Patience, I don't get it. What is there in the article that explains why a "white" person would identify as "black"?
Back to top
Patience
Mentor
Mentor


Joined: 13 Mar 2007
{Posts: 261 }
Location: Canada

PostPosted: Thu 26 Jul 2007 20:20    Post subject: Re: Why a "white" person would identify "black"? Reply with quote

Powell wrote:
Patience wrote:
This is a question that comes up in this forum many times and I think part of the reason can be found in this article.

http://www.detnews.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20070719/METRO/707190419/1003


Patience, I don't get it. What is there in the article that explains why a "white" person would identify as "black"?


Sorry, I did leap ahead in my thoughts here.

The article, without coming to the conclusion, reveals the idea that "white" involves a way of thinking and being in society. In a lot of ways it involves more of a belief system than a blood-line.

In "white" thinking there is a disconnect from the reality of the existence of a racially constructed society. According to the article in one breath "whites" say there is 'no discrimination against them but I don't want to live beside one.'

For many people of mixed ancestry, it's not easy to make step from the point of seeing and understanding the racial hierarchies from a clear view, to the position of denial in "white" thinking. How can you be "white" when you can't think "white?"

In some ways, maybe "white" doesn't have anything to do with phenotype at all.
Back to top
G-Man
Moderator
Moderator


Joined: 27 Nov 2004
{Posts: 2992 }

PostPosted: Thu 26 Jul 2007 20:40    Post subject: Re: Why a "white" person would identify "black"? Reply with quote

Patience wrote:

The article, without coming to the conclusion, reveals the idea that "white" involves a way of thinking and being in society. In a lot of ways it involves more of a belief system than a blood-line.

In "white" thinking there is a disconnect from the reality of the existence of a racially constructed society. According to the article in one breath "whites" say there is 'no discrimination against them but I don't want to live beside one.'


I was always under the impression that white was to many a racial category (yes, I know race isn't supposed to exist), but if it is a disconnect from the reality of the existence of a racially constructed society, what are we to make of white supremacists or white nationalists? Both acknowledge the reality of race and the existence of a racially constructed society. In their own way they are thinking "white" and are trying to get other whites to do the same. Indeed, according to someone like Samuel Francis, whites need to develop more racial consciousness like other races in the U.S.
Back to top
Powell
Guru
Guru


Joined: 27 Nov 2004
{Posts: 2462 }

PostPosted: Thu 26 Jul 2007 21:10    Post subject: Re: Why a "white" person would identify "black"? Reply with quote

G-Man wrote:
Patience wrote:

The article, without coming to the conclusion, reveals the idea that "white" involves a way of thinking and being in society. In a lot of ways it involves more of a belief system than a blood-line.

In "white" thinking there is a disconnect from the reality of the existence of a racially constructed society. According to the article in one breath "whites" say there is 'no discrimination against them but I don't want to live beside one.'


I was always under the impression that white was to many a racial category (yes, I know race isn't supposed to exist), but if it is a disconnect from the reality of the existence of a racially constructed society, what are we to make of white supremacists or white nationalists? Both acknowledge the reality of race and the existence of a racially constructed society. In their own way they are thinking "white" and are trying to get other whites to do the same. Indeed, according to someone like Samuel Francis, whites need to develop more racial consciousness like other races in the U.S.


I would also ask how there can be such a thing as a "white liberal" or "anti-racist white" since they don't "think white" (according to Parience's proposed definition)? There is no agreement on what "white" is or what "thinking white" means.
Back to top
Patience
Mentor
Mentor


Joined: 13 Mar 2007
{Posts: 261 }
Location: Canada

PostPosted: Thu 26 Jul 2007 23:36    Post subject: Reply with quote

quote G-Man:

but if it is a disconnect from the reality of the existence of a racially constructed society, what are we to make of white supremacists or white nationalists? Both acknowledge the reality of race and the existence of a racially constructed society.


Actually for these people it's an even more bizarre disconnect from reality. Lately they seem to be claiming that "white" people are being repressed and discriminated against.

quote Powell: I would also ask how there can be such a thing as a "white liberal" or "anti-racist white" since they don't "think white" (according to Parience's proposed definition)? There is no agreement on what "white" is or what "thinking white" means.

Perhaps if "white" is really more of a way of thinking and not in the phenotypes, there is no such thing as a "white liberal" or "anti-racist white."

It's also true that some people who claim to be liberal and/or anti-racists are merely riding a self-serving identity. I've met oppressive types claiming conservative affilliation as well as oppressive types claiming liberal affilliation----same type, different t-shirts.

Also, I'm not trying to make a declaration here. I'm throwing out ideas and concepts to further the investigation of the various interesting topics that arise on these boards, including the question, 'what does "white" mean?' It's easy to define socially but on a more emotional, personal and individual level, what is it about?
Back to top
Salsassin
SuperWizard
SuperWizard


Joined: 04 Apr 2005
{Posts: 3515 }

PostPosted: Thu 26 Jul 2007 23:43    Post subject: Reply with quote

Patience wrote:

Actually for these people it's an even more bizarre disconnect from reality. Lately they seem to be claiming that "white" people are being repressed and discriminated against.


Some are.
Back to top
Patience
Mentor
Mentor


Joined: 13 Mar 2007
{Posts: 261 }
Location: Canada

PostPosted: Fri 27 Jul 2007 11:23    Post subject: Reply with quote

Salsassin wrote:
Patience wrote:

Actually for these people it's an even more bizarre disconnect from reality. Lately they seem to be claiming that "white" people are being repressed and discriminated against.


Some are.


Where and in what way? (That's not a reality where I live.)
Back to top
pianoplayer111
Wizard
Wizard


Joined: 16 May 2007
{Posts: 429 }

PostPosted: Tue 31 Jul 2007 16:35    Post subject: Reply with quote

Well, Patience, you've posed a good question here.

I believe what Jaime means is that we often hear about it when blacks are discriminated against. When the reverse occurs, there is a lot of denial or silence...sort of like what privileged whites would do to oppressed minorities. Some people feel it is impossible for blacks to be racist in thoughts and actions. I vehemently disagree.

Anyone is capable of racism. Have you ever heard of a woman named Malaika Tamu Griffin?
Back to top
pianoplayer111
Wizard
Wizard


Joined: 16 May 2007
{Posts: 429 }

PostPosted: Tue 31 Jul 2007 16:56    Post subject: Reply with quote

I forget that you live in Canada (which I love! Very Happy ), but that case was particularly horrific. It is one of the few cases I know of where black-on-white racism was made public. It is rather extreme but not unheard of.

I remember seeing it on "America's Most Wanted". In Colorado, this African-American woman named Malaika Tamu Griffin was living in a fairly upscale neighborhood. She was known to be extremely hostile and racist to anyone who was not visibly black, including other minorities. She hated anyone of mixed race as well. She read racist literature and had an arsenal of weapons in her home, despite having a good career. A young white couple moved in next door to her...a young man named Jason Horsley and his girlfriend, Debbie. She decided that because they were not black, they were the enemy, and she terrorized them in the hope that they would move away. She physically attacked Debbie on at least one occasion, calling her a "white bitch".

It escalated one afternoon when Horsley, a construction worker, was preparing to work with some tools in the driveway. Griffin went outside and started verbally abusing him. He ignored her because it wasn't the first time she had displayed that behavior. Infuriated, she went inside her home and returned with a rifle. She shot him at close range in the back of his head and continued to shoot after he had slumped over, bleeding to death. Debbie called 911 but it was too late. He died. Griffin escaped temporarily, but was later picked up by the authorities. I don't know how long she will be behind bars.


*Note: I know all of this might seem off-topic, but it's worth mentioning. I know a black woman who is very racist towards her elderly Jewish neighbors, both of whom are very nice people. They invited her over for lunch one afternoon since they were new to the neighborhood and she slammed the door shut. She has said that she doesn't associate with "white folks".
Back to top
Salsassin
SuperWizard
SuperWizard


Joined: 04 Apr 2005
{Posts: 3515 }

PostPosted: Tue 31 Jul 2007 17:18    Post subject: Reply with quote

Patience wrote:
Salsassin wrote:
Patience wrote:

Actually for these people it's an even more bizarre disconnect from reality. Lately they seem to be claiming that "white" people are being repressed and discriminated against.


Some are.


Where and in what way? (That's not a reality where I live.)

I guess you haven't heard of tcases of white kids that go to school in inner cities or other predominant minority schools and are constantly beat up. Or that can be called anything but can't retaliate.
Back to top
Salsassin
SuperWizard
SuperWizard


Joined: 04 Apr 2005
{Posts: 3515 }

PostPosted: Tue 31 Jul 2007 17:32    Post subject: Reply with quote

Patience wrote:
Salsassin wrote:
Patience wrote:

Actually for these people it's an even more bizarre disconnect from reality. Lately they seem to be claiming that "white" people are being repressed and discriminated against.


Some are.


Where and in what way? (That's not a reality where I live.)

I guess you haven't heard of tcases of white kids that go to school in inner cities or other predominant minority schools and are constantly beat up. Or that can be called anything but can't retaliate.
Back to top
pianoplayer111
Wizard
Wizard


Joined: 16 May 2007
{Posts: 429 }

PostPosted: Tue 31 Jul 2007 17:53    Post subject: Reply with quote

Yes, Jaime, that is true. I attended schools like that and I learned to avoid being beaten up somehow. The black kids would want to fight if you so much as looked at them.

When I was in elementary school (attending public school for the first time at 10 years old), I remember this very clearly. A few weeks after school reopened, we had a new girl in class. She was white and obviously from a low-income family. She was plump, with short brown hair and a sweet personality. We became friends immediately. The black girls HATED her for no reason at all besides the fact that she was white. This one girl in particular was very cruel towards her. Ironically, the bully's name was Ebony Ivory!!! Laughing

Anyway, they wound up "jumping" her after school. They beat her up so badly. They broke her nose. I can still see her in tears with blood running down her shirt. She never returned to school again. I wonder what happened to her and where she is today and how she feels about black women because of what those little girls did to her. Our English teacher, a Jewish lady, chastised them for what they did. I think that even as young as they were, they were acting out racism.
Back to top
Powell
Guru
Guru


Joined: 27 Nov 2004
{Posts: 2462 }

PostPosted: Tue 31 Jul 2007 20:55    Post subject: Black Racism Reply with quote

pianoplayer111 wrote:
Yes, Jaime, that is true. I attended schools like that and I learned to avoid being beaten up somehow. The black kids would want to fight if you so much as looked at them.

When I was in elementary school (attending public school for the first time at 10 years old), I remember this very clearly. A few weeks after school reopened, we had a new girl in class. She was white and obviously from a low-income family. She was plump, with short brown hair and a sweet personality. We became friends immediately. The black girls HATED her for no reason at all besides the fact that she was white. This one girl in particular was very cruel towards her. Ironically, the bully's name was Ebony Ivory!!! Laughing

Anyway, they wound up "jumping" her after school. They beat her up so badly. They broke her nose. I can still see her in tears with blood running down her shirt. She never returned to school again. I wonder what happened to her and where she is today and how she feels about black women because of what those little girls did to her. Our English teacher, a Jewish lady, chastised them for what they did. I think that even as young as they were, they were acting out racism.


Many people seem to assume that a "racist" must always believe that his own "race" is at the top of the presumed hierarchy. For American blacks, that does not seem to be true. Based on their history, I would say that "black" American racism is usually based on a fear or belief in their own inferiority. Hating the people above you is probably as common as hating the people below you.
Back to top
kpauljohnson
Experienced User
Experienced User


Joined: 24 May 2007
{Posts: 129 }
Location: Danville, VA

PostPosted: Wed 01 Aug 2007 00:42    Post subject: Re: Black Racism Reply with quote

Hello Jaime, A.D., Pianoplayer, and all,

My 2 cents is that my two biracial half-sisters went through the D.C. public school system and were vilified as "yellow bellied sapsuckers" etc. until one of them became a basketball star in their high school, at which point the racial epithets stopped.

They were treated much better in their almost all- white college than in their almost all-black high school, but one of them has taught at the latter for many years and loves it.

Paul

Powell wrote:
pianoplayer111 wrote:
Yes, Jaime, that is true. I attended schools like that and I learned to avoid being beaten up somehow. The black kids would want to fight if you so much as looked at them.

When I was in elementary school (attending public school for the first time at 10 years old), I remember this very clearly. A few weeks after school reopened, we had a new girl in class. She was white and obviously from a low-income family. She was plump, with short brown hair and a sweet personality. We became friends immediately. The black girls HATED her for no reason at all besides the fact that she was white. This one girl in particular was very cruel towards her. Ironically, the bully's name was Ebony Ivory!!! Laughing

Anyway, they wound up "jumping" her after school. They beat her up so badly. They broke her nose. I can still see her in tears with blood running down her shirt. She never returned to school again. I wonder what happened to her and where she is today and how she feels about black women because of what those little girls did to her. Our English teacher, a Jewish lady, chastised them for what they did. I think that even as young as they were, they were acting out racism.


Many people seem to assume that a "racist" must always believe that his own "race" is at the top of the presumed hierarchy. For American blacks, that does not seem to be true. Based on their history, I would say that "black" American racism is usually based on a fear or belief in their own inferiority. Hating the people above you is probably as common as hating the people below you.
Back to top
Patience
Mentor
Mentor


Joined: 13 Mar 2007
{Posts: 261 }
Location: Canada

PostPosted: Wed 01 Aug 2007 11:58    Post subject: Reply with quote

Thank you for all for sharing your experiences.

When I first asked the question, it was in relation to a wider soci-economic and political picture that included "white" people but I think the personal experiences shared here raise another topic which is very relevent to this forum.

There seems to be a serious problem within the African American community with "racial" hierarchies and "racial" biases. It's a lot like the Tutsi and the Hutu of Rwanda, where these imagined divisions were established long time ago by "white" people but are then continued on by the very people who suffered and will suffer from this cultural system.

The honest attempt to try and erradicate the shame and hurt that AD Powell talks about, by trying to instill "black pride" can sometimes add fuel to this fire. "Black" is suddenly not an ethnic identity but an exclusive club that you are either admitted to or refused entry. "Black" becomes the same as "white" in that respect.
Back to top
G-Man
Moderator
Moderator


Joined: 27 Nov 2004
{Posts: 2992 }

PostPosted: Wed 01 Aug 2007 12:51    Post subject: Reply with quote

Patience wrote:
Salsassin wrote:
Patience wrote:

Actually for these people it's an even more bizarre disconnect from reality. Lately they seem to be claiming that "white" people are being repressed and discriminated against.


Some are.


Where and in what way? (That's not a reality where I live.)


According to Human Rights Watch's report on rape in U.S. prisons (which can be read here: http://www.hrw.org/reports/2001/prison/) whites, along with the mentally ill, developmentally disabled, the "weak", and homosexuals, are more likely to be targeted for rape and phyical assault in U.S. prisons.

Also, whites can be victims of "hate" crimes like anyone else.

Many white supremacist and white nationalist groups often target marginal whites (yes, they do exist) who live in communities where they may be targeted for abuse because they are white and perceived as privileged and powerful, despite not having two nickels to rub together.
Back to top
G-Man
Moderator
Moderator


Joined: 27 Nov 2004
{Posts: 2992 }

PostPosted: Wed 01 Aug 2007 13:10    Post subject: Re: Black Racism Reply with quote

Powell wrote:

Many people seem to assume that a "racist" must always believe that his own "race" is at the top of the presumed hierarchy. For American blacks, that does not seem to be true. Based on their history, I would say that "black" American racism is usually based on a fear or belief in their own inferiority. Hating the people above you is probably as common as hating the people below you.


Yeah I think that is the main distinction between black racial hate and white racial hate. Many black folks I know personally who really hate white people (and Jews) tend to mystify whites as thoroughly evil but mentally superior beings with supernatural evil powers.

In contrast, they view themselves and black people in general as virtuous but stupid (though they'd never admit this). They see themselves as people who have no self control or conscious action, and therefore, they have no choice but to fall for the "traps" whites set for them. To most of these people, whites simply wish harm on black folks and POOF harm befalls them. Everything from AIDS to spousal abuse is seen as the result of the evil machinations of white folks. A person raised with this kind of thinking can't help but hate white people, all of them, but be in awe of them too. Moreover, he can’t help but be convinced of his own mental inferiority as well.


However many whites who see themselves as the cream of the crop may be more racially hostile if their actual social situation isn't consistent with their view of themselves. I’ve encountered this more than once.
Back to top
Patience
Mentor
Mentor


Joined: 13 Mar 2007
{Posts: 261 }
Location: Canada

PostPosted: Wed 01 Aug 2007 15:32    Post subject: Re: Black Racism Reply with quote

G-Man wrote:
However many whites who see themselves as the cream of the crop may be more racially hostile if their actual social situation isn't consistent with their view of themselves. I’ve encountered this more than once.


Taking your observation a step further: although it's true that poor "whites" would express racial hostility in a forth right manner, "whites" of higher social status would express their hostility in much more subtle ways in keeping with their own social expectations. Damage is done either way.

How a person "black" or "white" expresses racism, depends on social status.

Also I think what you say about the racist thinking in the "black" community brings home the fact that we are all part of the problem and all caught up in a broken system.
Back to top
pianoplayer111
Wizard
Wizard


Joined: 16 May 2007
{Posts: 429 }

PostPosted: Wed 01 Aug 2007 17:25    Post subject: Reply with quote

G-Man, I see your points. There are so many nutty notions in people's minds. Rolling Eyes

Have any of you posted on or visited that Blackvoices website? I signed onto it out of curiosity to participate in what looked like an interesting discussion. I plan to not post on or visit that site again. I was appalled at the hatred spewed by these folks, most of whom I'm sure are black. Nearly every other thread was a racist diatribe, some of it about white people...most of it AA's looking down on Caribbean people who live in the US. This one woman was a real troll...she assumed multiple online identities but her words were always the same. She referred to young Jamaican girls as "dirty prostitutes" and claimed that all people from the Caribbean were "evil scum" who want to con AA's.

Then there was the guy who created a thread entitled "AIDS Was Created By White Men". He did not ONCE present proof of this. No factual evidence whatsoever. No credible links. When I pointed out that many white people have died from AIDS, he came at me with this nonsense about: "I don't care what your complexion is (I never mentioned my looks at all so I was puzzled), you're still a sista and you need to know the history of your people" ad nauseum. He skirted around my very direct comment by trying to rope me into this odd club of blackness, if you will. Most of the people on there are as bad as the white racist websites. Only unlike the white racists online, they are in denial of their racism.
Back to top
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   This topic is locked: you cannot edit posts or make replies.    The Study of Racialism Forum Index -> Improving U.S. Society All times are GMT
Goto page 1, 2, 3, 4, 5  Next
Page 1 of 5

 


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group